Monday, November 12, 2012
I have always prided myself on being able to see 'both sides of the argument', being able to switch arguments as the occasion arises. At best, it's being open-minded and being able to empathise. On a more negative note, it's being afraid to commit and not being able to come to a decision.
But recently, as I get further along in years and down this career path, I find myself being forced to crystallise my decisions and choose. I get less and less sympathy for 'maybes' or 'depends', and I find it no coincidence that the people most respected around me are those who kept to a particularly strong sense of self and principle.
One example - Amicus. I have known of their work and had the opportunity to become involved since high school, but have always stopped one step short of commitment. I was convinced that I could see the 'justifiable' side of the death penalty: Surely it is the strongest deterrent to violent crime possible? Surely the risk of executing an innocent person is worth the potential benefit of saving tens or hundreds more from horrific crimes? But recently, after learning more about it, I have come to the conclusion that even if the idea is rationally acceptable, the system is too dehumanising and imperfect to be workable in practice.
Another difficult one - tobacco litigation. Lawyers representing big tobacco companies never get it easy. The clients are not names that roll off the tongue easily and the work does not usually make for pleasant dinner conversation. Whether I would feel comfortable working on the defence for tobacco companies was always something I had considered but never came to a firm decision on. But a couple of months ago, I was asked the question bluntly and had to make a decision very quickly. I was no longer able to hide behind the excuse that it was only a theoretical possibility or that I can see both sides of the argument. It was extremely strange feeling whatever vague thoughts or feelings I have ever had on this issue suddenly surge into sharp focus. It was equally surprising how, when forced to choose, how clear the answer was.
Which leads me to think that my previous equivocation was simply an excuse not to decide. I wanted to please as many people as I can, so I decided to have no firm stand, caveating everything with '...depending on the circumstances', secretly hoping that they would never arise.
I still do not actively seek out tough choices, but when they do in fact happen, it almost always came as a sense of relief. It was as if another piece of the jigsaw had fallen into place, to complete the picture of 'who I am'.
..signing off..
3 dropped by